Words Are Not Neutral: The EU’s Century of Complicity Against Macedonians
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen arrived in Skopje on October 2, 2026, with the usual script: praise for EU accession progress, vague commitments, and empty promises regarding the systematic erasure of ethnic Macedonians in Greece and Bulgaria. Her visit—the final stop on a Balkan tour—was predictable. But words are not neutral. They can be a fig leaf for inaction—and when they are not backed by any written, legally binding document from the European Commission, they become complicity itself.
This is not about ancient history. It is about a living genocide that the European Union has enabled, facilitated, and continues to bury.
What Happened
Between 1904 and 1908, Greek armed bands—the andartes—conducted a systematic campaign of terror across Ottoman Macedonia. This was not random banditry. It was organized, financed, and encouraged by the Greek state. Greek officers in uniform led bands of hundreds. European consuls and intelligence agents documented the campaign in real time, and their reports were compiled and published in London in 1908 in Macedonia and the Reforms.
The pattern was consistent. In September 1905, a Greek band of 150 men pillaged every house in the village of Gherman, loaded the booty onto 55 horses, and abducted several women. One of them, a widow named Anghelina Dineva, never returned. In the same month, a band led by “Barba Gheorghi” killed an elderly man and his 18-year-old nephew between Poroi and Petritch, half-killing them with blows before finishing them with yataghans. Dionis Koleff and his servant were bound, tortured “with refinements of cruelty,” killed, and their corpses found “frightfully mutilated.”
A Greek band burst into the village of Armensko, driving the inhabitants into “indescribable panic,” then sacked the church and carried off the priest and two notables into the mountains.
Nearly 100 Macedonian laborers were drowned in the Aliakmonas River in May 1905. Twenty-five were killed at Isvor in 1907. Fifteen were slaughtered in front of their children near Katerini.
At Niaousta, Greek bands assembled Macedonian notables in the village square and ordered them to abandon the Exarchate, recognize the Patriarchate, and declare themselves Greek. They were given five days to decide, “under threat of extermination along with their fellow-villagers, and of seeing their villages burned.”
The campaign had a clear goal: destroy the Macedonian identity and replace it with a Greek one.
The “Bulgarian” Label: A Tool of Erasure
One crucial point must be explained. The Ottoman and Greek sources that documented these atrocities often referred to the victims as “Bulgarians.” This was not an ethnic description. It was a political and religious label imposed from outside.
Under the Ottoman millet system, Orthodox Christians were categorized by their church affiliation, not by ethnicity or language. The Bulgarian Exarchate, established in 1870, became a religious institution for Orthodox Christians in Macedonia and used Bulgarian as its liturgical and administrative language. Those who joined it were legally and administratively classified as “Bulgarians,” regardless of their ethnic self-identification. The Exarchate was never an ethnic census.
In reality, the population of Macedonia spoke Macedonian, not Bulgarian. Greek sources adopted the label “Bulgarian” to deny the existence of a distinct Macedonian identity. The label was a political and religious category imposed from outside, later weaponized by Greek and Bulgarian propaganda to deny that Macedonians existed as a distinct people.
The same tactic persists today. Greek and Bulgarian officials still describe Macedonians as “Slavic-speaking” or “Bulgarian-speaking” in order to avoid saying the word “Macedonian.” These labels are not neutral linguistic descriptions. They are the same instrument of erasure, updated for a new century.
The terminology of the perpetrators and their diplomats should not be mistaken for the identity of the victims. When Greek bands attacked “Bulgarian” villages, they were attacking Macedonians. When Greek consuls wrote about “Bulgarian-speaking populations,” they were describing Macedonians.
The Jelišić Standard
The ICTY Appeals Chamber in Prosecutor v. Jelišić established the legal standard for genocide. Genocide requires dolus specialis—the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a protected group as such. But proof of specific intent can be inferred from circumstances: systematic targeting, the scale of atrocities, the repetition of destructive acts, and the existence of a plan or policy.
Unlike Goran Jelišić, whose random killings and disturbed personality led the Trial Chamber to acquit him of genocide, the Greek campaign was neither random nor personality-driven. It was planned in the spring of 1904. It systematically targeted Macedonian villages, churches, schools, and community leaders. It operated under regulations defining the principal duty as prohibiting all contact with Bulgarians “under penalty of death.” It involved massacres, torture, rape, arson, forced conversion, and abduction.
This was not the suppression of a rebellion. It was the destruction of a people’s identity.
The EU’s Role
The European Union is not a passive bystander. It is a knowing accomplice.
Under Article 16 of the International Law Commission’s Articles on State Responsibility, a state that aids or assists another state in the commission of an internationally wrongful act bears responsibility if it does so with knowledge of the circumstances. All EU member states are parties to the Genocide Convention, which imposes an obligation to prevent and punish genocide.
The Prespa Agreement of 2018 is the clearest evidence of EU complicity. Negotiated under strong EU pressure and signed in the presence of EU representatives, the agreement required Macedonia to renounce the Macedonian minority in Greece and to construct a “common history” under Greek rules. It has been characterized by Macedonian organizations as a “Treaty of Genocide” and an act of “cultural genocide.”
The Macedonian Jury of Conscience found the EU “guilty of identity and cultural genocide.” As one analysis in Emerging Europe noted, “Greece has successfully framed its policy of cultural genocide against Macedonians as a ‘diplomatic dispute,’ and the world has blindly followed along.”
The EU has been repeatedly informed of these violations through UN mechanisms. It has done nothing.
Bulgaria, an EU member since 2007, also continues to deny the existence of a Macedonian minority within its borders. The EU has never held it accountable.
Why a Written Commitment Is Impossible—and Why That Excuses Nothing
The Commission’s defenders will say it cannot act. They are right on the law, and that is precisely the problem.
The European Union has no constitution. It has treaties. And those treaties place minority rights outside the Union’s competence. Article 4(2) of the Treaty on European Union requires the Union to respect the national identities of its member states. The Commission has stated this in writing:
“Member States retain exclusive competence as regards the regulation of the legal status of the use of national, regional and minority languages, including the recognition of certain language rights on their territories.”
And again:
“The EU has no competence to impose changes to the political, administrative and institutional framework that exists in the Member States as regards the status of national minorities… Member States have general powers to legislate on national minorities, in particular on questions related to the recognition of the status of such minorities.”
The Court of Justice of the European Union confirmed the limit in 2022: “The European Union has no competence in respect of the rights of persons belonging to national minorities.”
So the Commission cannot issue a regulation, a directive, or a decision guaranteeing Macedonian language, history, culture, and religion in Greece and Bulgaria. It cannot enter a treaty that does so. If it tried, the Court would annul it.
This is not an excuse. It is the reason verbal promises are worthless.
The Union can condition accession on minority protection. It can fund minority-language projects. It can pass resolutions. It cannot compel Greece or Bulgaria to recognise a Macedonian minority. And it knows it.
So when the President of the Commission stands in Skopje and speaks warmly of Macedonian identity and language, she is speaking where she has no power to bind and remaining silent where she has the power to act. That is the choice. And that choice is complicity.
The Choice
The Genocide Convention obligates all contracting parties to prevent and punish genocide. All EU member states bear this obligation. They have failed.
The current VMRO government in North Macedonia has a unique opportunity. The evidence is documented. The legal framework exists. The historical record is clear. What is needed now is political will.
North Macedonia should convene its diaspora experts, present the evidence to the international legal community, and demand recognition of the Macedonian genocide. It should hold the perpetrators accountable—including the European Union and its member states.
The path forward does not run through Brussels regulation. It runs through the Council of Europe—the Framework Convention for the Protection of National Minorities and the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages—and through bilateral and multilateral treaties that bind states directly. Greece and Bulgaria have refused to sign these instruments. That refusal should be named, in public, at every international forum where they claim to uphold human rights.
The Macedonian people have waited long enough.
The suffering was not random. It was not isolated. It was not merely a product of war.
It was genocide. And it continues today.
Sources and Further Reading
Primary contemporaneous sources (1904–1908)
· Draganof, Macedonia and the Reforms (London: Hazell, Watson and Viney, 1908). Compilation of British, French, Russian, and Austro-Hungarian diplomatic and consular reports from Ottoman Macedonia, including the accounts of Gherman, Poroi–Petritch, Cadino, Armensko, Staritchany, and the Niaousta forced-conversion campaign.
· H. N. Brailsford, Macedonia: Its Races and Their Future (London: Methuen & Co., 1906). Eyewitness account by a British journalist and Macedonia Relief Fund investigator.
· “The Macedonian Danger,” The Spectator, 3 August 1907, p. 14.
· “600 Macedonians Coming: Atrocities Still Going On in Turkey,” The New York Times, 15 December 1906.
· “Greek-Bulgarian Battles: Twenty-four Greeks Killed in One Fight in Macedonia,” The New York Times, 22 October 1904.
· Oschima: The Story of a Small Village in Western Macedonia, Pollitecon Balkan Literature Portal digital collection.
Legal sources
· Prosecutor v. Goran Jelišić, Case No. IT-95-10-T, Trial Chamber Judgement, 14 December 1999.
· Prosecutor v. Goran Jelišić, Case No. IT-95-10-A, Appeals Chamber Judgement, 5 July 2001.
· Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, adopted 9 December 1948, Article II.
· Statute of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, Article 4.
· International Law Commission, Draft Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts (2001), Article 16 and Commentary.
· Treaty on European Union, Article 4(2).
· Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, Article 218.
· Final Agreement for the Settlement of the Differences as Described in United Nations Security Council Resolutions 817 (1993) and 845 (1993) [Prespa Agreement], Greece–North Macedonia, 17 June 2018.
Scholarship and documentation
· Tassos Kostopoulos, “How the North was won: Épuration ethnique, échange des populations et politique de colonisation dans la Macédoine grecque,” European Journal of Turkish Studies, No. 12 (2011).
· Tamás Molnár, “Complicity in International State Responsibility: Structural Paradoxes and Dynamic Shifts,” European Papers, Vol. 2023, No. 2.
· M. Tasheva & K. Minoski, “The Exodus of the Macedonians from Aegean Macedonia – A Process of Individual and Collective Trauma,” Sociological Review (University of Ss. Cyril and Methodius, Skopje, 2017).
· United Macedonian Diaspora, Eliminating Ethnic, Linguistic, and Religious Discrimination of the Macedonian Minority in Albania, Bulgaria, and Greece, Submission to the OHCHR (2019).
· United Macedonian Diaspora, Submission to the United Nations Universal Periodic Review regarding Macedonia and the Macedonians (2019).
· Macedonian Human Rights Movement International (MHRMI), Frame It, Win It, Eradicate It: The Cultural Genocide of Macedonians (Toronto, 2018).
Press and advocacy coverage
· “Macedonian Jury of Conscience finds EU guilty of identity and cultural genocide,” Online Opinion, 28 May 2026 (reporting on the Jury of Conscience convened 13 May 2025).
· “Greece accused of ‘genocide’ of Macedonian people,” Anadolu Agency, 17 July 2018.
· “You wouldn’t give away your ethnic identity. So why should Macedonians?,” Emerging Europe, 14 September 2020.
· Amnesty International, “EU/Israel: Review of the EU’s relations with Israel welcome but devastatingly late,” 20 May 2025 (cited for the EU’s double standards on genocide, not for Macedonia).
Пишува од Вашингтон, Д.Ц., САД, STEVE GLIGOROV, J.D., Esq., B.S., Cert. in Int’l Trade Law & Int’l Comm. Arb., Original Co-Founder of the United Macedonian Diaspora
Ставовите се лични ставови на авторите и Pelanet.mk не носи одговорност за нив.